Study Finds Majority of Americans Now Prefer Hotels Over Airbnb for Holidays
Survey data on holiday travel patterns involving more than 2,000 United States travelers indicates a rising preference for hotels as concerns grow about added fees, cleaning requirements, and pricing clarity in short-term rentals. Pools, gyms, and complimentary breakfast remain major draw cards, with 73 percent of hotel fans saying these perks seal the deal. People also like the relief of skipping cleaning checklists and unexpected charges. Approximately 62 percent say those issues encourage them to choose hotels. Another large group values simple booking and cancellation options, two features that are particularly helpful during busy travel months.
One of the most striking data points centers on pricing clarity. Up to 76 percent of people believe hotels present the final cost in a way that is easy to understand. Transparency matters more as travelers budget for larger family gatherings and seasonal plans.
Why Short-Term Rentals Still Hold Interest
Image via Canva/Pixelshot
Short-term rentals maintain a strong following, and their supporters are well-informed about their preferences. About 75 percent enjoy the space and privacy, while 68 percent appreciate having a kitchen and a setup that feels more familiar than a standard room. More than half say rentals are better suited for groups and families, which makes sense for holiday trips that involve extended stays or shared spaces.
At the same time, many travelers express concern about housing affordability in popular destinations. More than 70 percent believe rentals increase local housing costs, and support for limiting them in high-demand areas reaches 61 percent. Younger adults voice the strongest concern. Despite these concerns, the country remains divided. Half say they would avoid renting during the holidays because of the housing impact, while the other half say the right price and location still win.
How Geography Shapes the Split
While the national picture favors hotels, several states trend in the opposite direction. North Carolina, South Carolina, Colorado, Oregon, California, Maine, and Arkansas lean toward short-term rentals this season. This is likely because larger homes, cabins, and vacation properties are widely available and often preferred for group stays within these regions.