10 Private Islands You Can Rent for Cheap
Owning your own island may sound like something reserved for tech billionaires or movie stars, but renting one is surprisingly within reach. Some islands, even in Europe and the Caribbean, go for less than a night at a standard hotel.
These rentals range from lighthouse outposts to artist-designed floating cabins, each offering rare privacy and a real break from crowds. It’s important to note that rental prices fluctuate and are not permanently fixed, though most of these quoted values below fall within historically plausible ranges.
Porer Island, Croatia – $632/Week
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Porer Island is located in the Adriatic Sea, southwest of Premantura. It covers less than half an acre and features a 19th-century lighthouse still in operation. The only accommodation is in the keeper’s stone quarters directly beneath the lighthouse. Access requires a boat, and the site is managed by Croatia’s Ministry of Maritime Affairs.
Langholmen Island, Norway – $45/Night
Credit: Airbnb
Set in a Norwegian fjord, Langholmen feels like it belongs in another century. The simple wooden cabin has no electricity, but solar lights and a wood-heated sauna help. The price is about $45 per night. It’s accessible by kayak and surrounded by steep hills and cold, clear water.
Utter Inn, Sweden – $1,750/Week
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Utter Inn is a floating art installation by artist Mikael Genberg on Lake Mälaren near Västerås, Sweden. The structure includes a small red cabin above water and a bedroom located 3 meters below the surface, with panoramic underwater windows. The property is accessible by boat and offers complete seclusion.
Davaar Island, Scotland – $129/Night
Credit: Wikipedia
At low tide, a narrow causeway connects this tidal island to mainland Scotland. The keeper’s cottage is cozy and comes with basic amenities and heat. Wi-Fi can be unpredictable, but you’re really here for the coastal hikes and sea caves. Guests have a short window each day to cross on foot.
Fort Morgan Cay, Honduras – $249/Night
Credit: Airbnb
This seven-acre island is now a solar-powered retreat. It includes a whole villa, staff, kayaks, and even snorkeling gear. You can book the entire island for your group—up to 16 people. It’s surrounded by mangroves and Caribbean reef waters.
Coco Plum Caye, Belize – $1,540/Week
Credit: Instagram
A single overwater cabana sits on this private Belizean island. It’s eight miles offshore, near the Belize Barrier Reef. Meals are prepared onsite, and the rate includes transfers. The setup is deliberately minimal to focus on snorkeling, sea breezes, and watching the horizon stretch in every direction.
Dunbar Rock, Honduras – $1,197/Week
Credit: Tripadvisor
Dunbar Rock is located off the coast of Guanaja, Honduras. The main structure is a villa perched atop a limestone outcrop in the Caribbean. The island accommodates scuba divers and travelers accessing nearby reefs. Once associated with the pirate Blackbeard, it now operates as a low-density private resort.
Little Peter Oasis, Belize – $1,450/Night
Credit: Facebook
This island isn’t large, but the luxury is scaled to fit. The single villa includes solar power, private staff, reef views, and a well-stocked kitchen. It’s designed for couples or small groups. Kayaks and snorkel gear are included, and it’s just far enough from shore to feel completely separate.
Robert’s Caye, Belize – $155/Night
Credit: Belize
Robert’s Caye is all about overwater cabins and casual pacing. At one acre, it’s walkable in minutes. The thatched cabanas are perched on stilts above the sea, and meals are part of the deal. It’s part of the Roberts Grove resort network, often used for low-key snorkeling trips.
Watch Island Lodge, New York – $995/Night
Credit: Zillow
Watch Island is situated in the Thousand Islands region of the St. Lawrence River near Clayton, New York. It features a lodge-style house with a private dock, gardens, and water access. The island accommodates families or groups and is accessible by a short boat ride from the mainland.